Montauk Tartara
Chunked Yellowfin Tuna, Avocado, Fresh Mango with Lemon Champagne Vinaigrette
Calamari Arrabiata
Fried Calamari Tossed in a Spicy Marinara Sauce
Pulpo Castaways
Grilled Portuguese Octopus, Saffron Potatoes, Red Onions, on a Bed of Chic Pea Puree with Crispy Artichoke Hearts
Mozzarella Napoleon
Fresh Mozzarella, Sliced Heirloom Tomatoes, Roasted Pepper with Infused Basil E.V.O.O.
Mamas Meatballs
Homemade meatball Marinara with Ricotta Cheese
Classic Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
With Assorted Cocktail Sauces
Wild Salmon
8 oz salmon grilled with bastami rice and caper sauce.
Sea Scallops
Seared sea scallops on a bed of chic pea puree with piccata sauce.
Tuna
10 oz espresso encrusted, fresh yellowfin tuna, caramelized onions, fresh ginger with fennel seed, prosecco emulsion.
Inferno
Homemade Fresh Mozzarella, Mutti Tomato, Pepperoni, Meatball and Sausage
Tartufata
Mixed Italian Cheeses, Caramelized Onion and Fresh Truffles
Margarita
Homemade Fresh Mozzarella, Mutti Tomato & Basil
Ortolana
Homemade Fior Di Latte Cheese, Mutti Tomato, Grilled Vegetables
San Danielle
Homemade Fresh Mozzarella, Baby Arugula, Cherry Tomato, Aged Prosciutto - Finished with Shaved Parmesan
Bianco
Fresh Ricotta Cheese, Homemade Fior Di Latte, Garlic, Italian Oregano & E.V.O.O.
Çhicken Parmigiana
Breaded sauteed chicken breast with marinara and fresh mozzarella.
Chicken Milanese
Baby arugula, red onion and shaved parmesan with imported balsamic glazed vinaigrette.
Fresh Pappardelle Pasta
With assorted meat bolognese.
Montauk Edgar's Penne Vodka
Grey Goose with imported buratta.
Linguine
Red or white clam sauce.
Grandma's Lasagna
With bolognese and bechamel sauce.
Black Angus Filet Mignon
10 oz center cut broiled with grilled mushroom cap.
Lamb Chop
Lamb chop broiled, marinated with herbs and served with a mediterranean sauce.
Beet Salad
Fresh Marinated Beets, Crumbled Feta Cheese, Candied Walnuts with Balsamic Vinaigrette
House Salad
Mesclun Greens, Baby Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumber with House Vinaigrette
Watermelon Salad
Fresh Watermelon, Feta Cheese, Heirloom Tomatoes with Balsamic Glaze
Classic Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce with Creamy Caesar Dressing & Croutons
Kenny's Castaways Menu brings a fresh, beach-town comfort that fits perfectly with its Montauk address at 432 W Lake Dr. The dishes lean into bold flavors without trying too hard, and you can feel the relaxed atmosphere on every plate. Start with something easy to share, like crispy calamari or a punchy seafood appetizer that pairs well with a chilled drink. Moving through the mains, grilled options and hearty sandwiches hit the spot after a day near the water, while the seafood plates feel like a quiet nod to the town’s coastal roots.
What stands out is the balance between familiar favorites and seasonal touches. Whether you’re craving something rich or keeping it light, the menu gives you room to explore without feeling overwhelmed. It’s the kind of place where you glance around, see everyone enjoying something different, and feel comfortable ordering whatever catches your eye.